Exemplo n.º 1
0
SSATmp* TraceBuilder::preOptimizeAssertLoc(IRInstruction* inst) {
  auto const locId = inst->extra<AssertLoc>()->locId;
  auto const prevType = localType(locId, DataTypeGeneric);
  auto const typeParam = inst->typeParam();

  if (!prevType.equals(Type::None) && !typeParam.strictSubtypeOf(prevType)) {
    if (!prevType.subtypeOf(typeParam)) {
      /* Task #2553746
       * This is triggering for a case where the tracked state says the local is
       * InitNull but the AssertLoc says it's Str. */
      static auto const error =
        StringData::GetStaticString("Internal error: static analysis was "
                                    "wrong about a local variable's type.");
      auto* errorInst = m_irFactory.gen(RaiseError, inst->marker(), cns(error));
      inst->become(&m_irFactory, errorInst);

      // It's not a disaster to generate this in unreachable code for
      // now. t2590033.
      if (false) {
        assert_log(false,  [&]{
            IRTrace& mainTrace = trace()->isMain() ? *trace()
                                                   : *(trace()->main());
            return folly::format("\npreOptimizeAssertLoc: prevType: {} "
                                 "typeParam: {}\nin instr: {}\nin trace: {}\n",
                                 prevType.toString(), typeParam.toString(),
                                 inst->toString(), mainTrace.toString()).str();
          });
      }
    } else {
      inst->convertToNop();
    }
  }
  return nullptr;
}
Exemplo n.º 2
0
SSATmp* TraceBuilder::preOptimizeAssertLoc(IRInstruction* inst) {
  auto const locId = inst->getExtra<AssertLoc>()->locId;
  auto const prevType = getLocalType(locId);
  auto const typeParam = inst->getTypeParam();

  if (!prevType.equals(Type::None) && !typeParam.strictSubtypeOf(prevType)) {
    assert(prevType.subtypeOf(typeParam));
    inst->convertToNop();
  }
  return nullptr;
}
Exemplo n.º 3
0
void insert_assertions_step(const php::Func& func,
                            const Bytecode& bcode,
                            const State& state,
                            std::bitset<kMaxTrackedLocals> mayReadLocalSet,
                            bool lastStackOutputObvious,
                            Gen gen) {
  for (size_t i = 0; i < state.locals.size(); ++i) {
    if (options.FilterAssertions) {
      if (i < mayReadLocalSet.size() && !mayReadLocalSet.test(i)) {
        continue;
      }
    }
    auto const realT = state.locals[i];
    auto const op = makeAssert<bc::AssertObjL,bc::AssertTL>(
      borrow(func.locals[i]), realT
    );
    if (op) gen(*op);
  }

  if (!options.InsertStackAssertions) return;

  // Skip asserting the top of the stack if it just came immediately
  // out of an 'obvious' instruction.  (See hasObviousStackOutput.)
  assert(state.stack.size() >= bcode.numPop());
  auto i = size_t{0};
  auto stackIdx = state.stack.size() - 1;
  if (lastStackOutputObvious) {
    ++i, --stackIdx;
  }

  /*
   * This doesn't need to account for ActRecs on the fpiStack, because
   * no instruction in an FPI region can ever consume a stack value
   * from above the pre-live ActRec.
   */
  for (; i < bcode.numPop(); ++i, --stackIdx) {
    auto const realT = state.stack[stackIdx];

    if (options.FilterAssertions &&
        !realT.strictSubtypeOf(stack_flav(realT))) {
      continue;
    }

    auto const op = makeAssert<bc::AssertObjStk,bc::AssertTStk>(
      static_cast<int32_t>(i), realT
    );
    if (op) gen(*op);
  }
}
Exemplo n.º 4
0
TEST(Type, Hierarchies) {
  auto const program = folly::make_unique<php::Program>();
  program->units.push_back(make_test_unit());
  auto const unit = borrow(program->units.back());
  auto const func = [&]() -> borrowed_ptr<php::Func> {
    for (auto& f : unit->funcs) {
      if (f->name->isame(s_test.get())) return borrow(f);
    }
    return nullptr;
  }();
  EXPECT_TRUE(func != nullptr);

  auto const ctx = Context { unit, func };
  Index idx{borrow(program)};

  // load classes in hierarchy
  auto const clsBase = idx.resolve_class(ctx, s_Base.get());
  if (!clsBase) EXPECT_TRUE(false);
  auto const clsA = idx.resolve_class(ctx, s_A.get());
  if (!clsA) EXPECT_TRUE(false);
  auto const clsB = idx.resolve_class(ctx, s_B.get());
  if (!clsB) EXPECT_TRUE(false);
  auto const clsAA = idx.resolve_class(ctx, s_AA.get());
  if (!clsAA) EXPECT_TRUE(false);
  auto const clsAB = idx.resolve_class(ctx, s_AB.get());
  if (!clsAB) EXPECT_TRUE(false);
  auto const clsBA = idx.resolve_class(ctx, s_BA.get());
  if (!clsBA) EXPECT_TRUE(false);
  auto const clsBB = idx.resolve_class(ctx, s_BB.get());
  if (!clsBB) EXPECT_TRUE(false);
  auto const clsBAA = idx.resolve_class(ctx, s_BAA.get());
  if (!clsBAA) EXPECT_TRUE(false);
  auto const clsTestClass = idx.resolve_class(ctx, s_TestClass.get());
  if (!clsTestClass) EXPECT_TRUE(false);
  auto const clsNonUnique = idx.resolve_class(ctx, s_NonUnique.get());
  if (!clsNonUnique) EXPECT_TRUE(false);

  // make *exact type* and *sub type* types and objects for all loaded classes
  auto const objExactBaseTy = objExact(*clsBase);
  auto const subObjBaseTy   = subObj(*clsBase);
  auto const clsExactBaseTy = clsExact(*clsBase);
  auto const subClsBaseTy   = subCls(*clsBase);

  auto const objExactATy    = objExact(*clsA);
  auto const subObjATy      = subObj(*clsA);
  auto const clsExactATy    = clsExact(*clsA);
  auto const subClsATy      = subCls(*clsA);

  auto const objExactAATy    = objExact(*clsAA);
  auto const subObjAATy      = subObj(*clsAA);
  auto const clsExactAATy    = clsExact(*clsAA);
  auto const subClsAATy      = subCls(*clsAA);

  auto const objExactABTy    = objExact(*clsAB);
  auto const subObjABTy      = subObj(*clsAB);
  auto const clsExactABTy    = clsExact(*clsAB);
  auto const subClsABTy      = subCls(*clsAB);

  auto const objExactBTy    = objExact(*clsB);
  auto const subObjBTy      = subObj(*clsB);
  auto const clsExactBTy    = clsExact(*clsB);
  auto const subClsBTy      = subCls(*clsB);

  auto const objExactBATy    = objExact(*clsBA);
  auto const subObjBATy      = subObj(*clsBA);
  auto const clsExactBATy    = clsExact(*clsBA);
  auto const subClsBATy      = subCls(*clsBA);

  auto const objExactBBTy    = objExact(*clsBB);
  auto const subObjBBTy      = subObj(*clsBB);
  auto const clsExactBBTy    = clsExact(*clsBB);
  auto const subClsBBTy      = subCls(*clsBB);

  auto const objExactBAATy    = objExact(*clsBAA);
  auto const subObjBAATy      = subObj(*clsBAA);
  auto const clsExactBAATy    = clsExact(*clsBAA);
  auto const subClsBAATy      = subCls(*clsBAA);

  auto const objExactTestClassTy = objExact(*clsTestClass);
  auto const subObjTestClassTy   = subObj(*clsTestClass);
  auto const clsExactTestClassTy = clsExact(*clsTestClass);
  auto const subClsTestClassTy   = subCls(*clsTestClass);

  auto const objExactNonUniqueTy = objExact(*clsNonUnique);
  auto const subObjNonUniqueTy   = subObj(*clsNonUnique);
  auto const clsExactNonUniqueTy = clsExact(*clsNonUnique);
  auto const subClsNonUniqueTy   = subCls(*clsNonUnique);

  // check that type from object and type are the same (obnoxious test)
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(objExactBaseTy), clsExactBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(subObjBaseTy), subClsBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(objExactATy), clsExactATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(subObjATy), subClsATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(objExactAATy), clsExactAATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(subObjAATy), subClsAATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(objExactABTy), clsExactABTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(subObjABTy), subClsABTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(objExactBTy), clsExactBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(subObjBTy), subClsBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(objExactBATy), clsExactBATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(subObjBATy), subClsBATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(objExactBBTy), clsExactBBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(subObjBBTy), subClsBBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(objExactBAATy), clsExactBAATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(subObjBAATy), subClsBAATy);

  // both subobj(A) and subcls(A) of no_override class A change to exact types
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(objExactABTy), subClsABTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(objcls(subObjABTy), clsExactABTy);

  // a T= is a subtype of itself but not a strict subtype
  // also a T= is in a "could be" relationship with itself.
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(objExactBaseTy).subtypeOf(clsExactBaseTy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(objExactBaseTy).strictSubtypeOf(objcls(objExactBaseTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(objExactBAATy).subtypeOf(clsExactBAATy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(clsExactBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(objExactBAATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(clsExactBAATy.couldBe(clsExactBAATy));

  // Given the hierarchy A <- B <- C where A is the base then:
  // B= is not in any subtype relationshipt with a A= or C=.
  // Neither they are in "could be" relationships.
  // Overall T= sets are always disjoint.
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(objExactBATy).subtypeOf(clsExactBaseTy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(objExactBATy).subtypeOf(clsExactBTy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(objExactBATy).subtypeOf(clsExactBAATy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(clsExactBATy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(objExactBaseTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(clsExactBATy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(objExactBTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(clsExactBATy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(objExactBAATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(clsExactBATy.couldBe(objcls(objExactBaseTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(objExactBATy).couldBe(clsExactBTy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(clsExactBATy.couldBe(objcls(objExactBAATy)));

  // any T= is both a subtype and strict subtype of T<=.
  // Given the hierarchy A <- B <- C where A is the base then:
  // C= is a subtype and a strict subtype of B<=, ?B<=, A<= and ?A<=.
  // The "could be" relationship also holds.
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(objExactATy).subtypeOf(subClsATy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(objExactBAATy).subtypeOf(subClsBaseTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjBaseTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(objExactBAATy).subtypeOf(subClsBTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjBTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(clsExactBAATy.subtypeOf(objcls(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(clsExactBAATy.subtypeOf(objcls(subObjBAATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjBAATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(objExactATy).strictSubtypeOf(subClsATy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(objExactBAATy).strictSubtypeOf(subClsBaseTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjBaseTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(objExactBAATy).strictSubtypeOf(subClsBTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjBTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(clsExactBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(clsExactBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(subObjBAATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjBAATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(objExactATy).couldBe(subClsATy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(objExactBAATy).couldBe(subClsBaseTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.couldBe(opt(subObjBaseTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(objExactBAATy).couldBe(subClsBTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.couldBe(opt(subObjBTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(clsExactBAATy.couldBe(objcls(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.couldBe(opt(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(clsExactBAATy.couldBe(objcls(subObjBAATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objExactBAATy.couldBe(opt(subObjBAATy)));

  // a T<= is a subtype of itself but not a strict subtype
  // also a T<= is in a "could be" relationship with itself
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(subObjBaseTy).subtypeOf(subClsBaseTy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjBaseTy).strictSubtypeOf(objcls(subObjBaseTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(subObjBAATy).subtypeOf(subClsBAATy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subClsBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(subObjBAATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subClsBAATy.couldBe(subClsBAATy));

  // a T<= type is in no subtype relationship with T=.
  // However a T<= is in a "could be" relationship with T=.
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjATy).subtypeOf(clsExactATy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjATy).strictSubtypeOf(clsExactATy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(clsExactATy.couldBe(objcls(subObjATy)));

  // Given 2 types A and B in no inheritance relationship then
  // A<= and B<= are in no subtype or "could be" relationship.
  // Same if one of the 2 types is an optional type
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjATy).subtypeOf(clsExactBTy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjATy).strictSubtypeOf(clsExactBTy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjATy.subtypeOf(opt(objExactBTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjATy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(objExactBTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(clsExactATy.couldBe(objcls(subObjBTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objExactATy.couldBe(opt(subObjBTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjBTy).subtypeOf(clsExactATy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBTy.subtypeOf(opt(objExactATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjBTy).strictSubtypeOf(clsExactATy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBTy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(objExactATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(clsExactBTy.couldBe(objcls(subObjATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objExactBTy.couldBe(opt(subObjATy)));

  // Given the hierarchy A <- B <- C where A is the base then:
  // C<= is a subtype and a strict subtype of B<=, ?B<=, A<= and ?A<=.
  // It is also in a "could be" relationship with all its ancestors
  // (including optional)
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(subObjBAATy).subtypeOf(subClsBaseTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBAATy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjBaseTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(subObjBAATy).subtypeOf(subClsBTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBAATy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjBTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subClsBAATy.subtypeOf(objcls(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBAATy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(subObjBAATy).strictSubtypeOf(subClsBaseTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjBaseTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(subObjBAATy).strictSubtypeOf(subClsBTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjBTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subClsBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBAATy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(subObjBAATy).couldBe(subClsBaseTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBAATy.couldBe(opt(subObjBaseTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(subObjBAATy).couldBe(subClsBTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBAATy.couldBe(opt(subObjBTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subClsBAATy.couldBe(objcls(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBAATy.couldBe(opt(subObjBATy)));

  // Given the hierarchy A <- B <- C where A is the base then:
  // A<= is not in a subtype neither a strict subtype with B<=, ?B<=, A<=
  // ?A<=. However A<= is in a "could be" relationship with all its
  // children (including optional)
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjBaseTy).subtypeOf(subClsATy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjBaseTy).subtypeOf(subClsBTy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjBTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subClsBaseTy.subtypeOf(objcls(subObjAATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjAATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subClsBaseTy.subtypeOf(objcls(subObjABTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjABTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjBaseTy).subtypeOf(subClsBATy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subClsBaseTy.subtypeOf(objcls(subObjBBTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjBBTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subClsBaseTy.subtypeOf(objcls(subObjBAATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.subtypeOf(opt(subObjBAATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjBaseTy).strictSubtypeOf(subClsATy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjBaseTy).strictSubtypeOf(subClsBTy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjBTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subClsBaseTy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(subObjAATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjAATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subClsBaseTy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(subObjABTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjABTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(objcls(subObjBaseTy).strictSubtypeOf(subClsBATy));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subClsBaseTy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(subObjBBTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjBBTy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subClsBaseTy.strictSubtypeOf(objcls(subObjBAATy)));
  EXPECT_FALSE(subObjBaseTy.strictSubtypeOf(opt(subObjBAATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(subObjBaseTy).couldBe(subClsATy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBaseTy.couldBe(opt(subObjATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(subObjBaseTy).couldBe(subClsBTy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBaseTy.couldBe(opt(subObjBTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subClsBaseTy.couldBe(objcls(subObjAATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBaseTy.couldBe(opt(subObjAATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subClsBaseTy.couldBe(objcls(subObjABTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBaseTy.couldBe(opt(subObjABTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(objcls(subObjBaseTy).couldBe(subClsBATy));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBaseTy.couldBe(opt(subObjBATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subClsBaseTy.couldBe(objcls(subObjBBTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBaseTy.couldBe(opt(subObjBBTy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subClsBaseTy.couldBe(objcls(subObjBAATy)));
  EXPECT_TRUE(subObjBaseTy.couldBe(opt(subObjBAATy)));

  // check union_of and commonAncestor API
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsA).commonAncestor(*clsB)).same(*clsBase));
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsB).commonAncestor(*clsA)).same(*clsBase));
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsAA).commonAncestor(*clsAB)).same(*clsA));
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsAB).commonAncestor(*clsAA)).same(*clsA));
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsA).commonAncestor(*clsBAA)).same(*clsBase));
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsBAA).commonAncestor(*clsA)).same(*clsBase));
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsBAA).commonAncestor(*clsB)).same(*clsB));
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsB).commonAncestor(*clsBAA)).same(*clsB));
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsBAA).commonAncestor(*clsBB)).same(*clsB));
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsBB).commonAncestor(*clsBAA)).same(*clsB));
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsAA).commonAncestor(*clsBase)).same(*clsBase));
  EXPECT_TRUE((*(*clsBase).commonAncestor(*clsAA)).same(*clsBase));
  EXPECT_FALSE((*clsAA).commonAncestor(*clsTestClass));
  EXPECT_FALSE((*clsTestClass).commonAncestor(*clsAA));
  EXPECT_FALSE((*clsBAA).commonAncestor(*clsNonUnique));
  EXPECT_FALSE((*clsNonUnique).commonAncestor(*clsBAA));

  // check union_of
  // union of subCls
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsATy, subClsBTy), subClsBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsAATy, subClsABTy), subClsATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsATy, subClsBAATy), subClsBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsBAATy, subClsBTy), subClsBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsBAATy, subClsBBTy), subClsBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsAATy, subClsBaseTy), subClsBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsAATy, subClsTestClassTy), TCls);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsBAATy, subClsNonUniqueTy), TCls);
  // union of subCls and clsExact mixed
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactATy, subClsBTy), subClsBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsAATy, clsExactABTy), subClsATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactATy, subClsBAATy), subClsBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsBAATy, clsExactBTy), subClsBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactBAATy, subClsBBTy), subClsBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsAATy, clsExactBaseTy), subClsBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactAATy, subClsTestClassTy), TCls);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subClsBAATy, clsExactNonUniqueTy), TCls);
  // union of clsExact
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactATy, clsExactBTy), subClsBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactAATy, clsExactABTy), subClsATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactATy, clsExactBAATy), subClsBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactBAATy, clsExactBTy), subClsBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactBAATy, clsExactBBTy), subClsBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactAATy, clsExactBaseTy), subClsBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactAATy, subClsTestClassTy), TCls);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(clsExactBAATy, clsExactNonUniqueTy), TCls);
  // union of subObj
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjATy, subObjBTy), subObjBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjAATy, subObjABTy), subObjATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjATy, subObjBAATy), subObjBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjBAATy, subObjBTy), subObjBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjBAATy, subObjBBTy), subObjBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjAATy, subObjBaseTy), subObjBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjAATy, subObjTestClassTy), TObj);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjBAATy, subObjNonUniqueTy), TObj);
  // union of subObj and objExact mixed
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactATy, subObjBTy), subObjBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjAATy, objExactABTy), subObjATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactATy, subObjBAATy), subObjBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjBAATy, objExactBTy), subObjBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactBAATy, subObjBBTy), subObjBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjAATy, objExactBaseTy), subObjBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactAATy, subObjTestClassTy), TObj);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjBAATy, objExactNonUniqueTy), TObj);
  // union of objExact
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactATy, objExactBTy), subObjBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactAATy, objExactABTy), subObjATy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactATy, objExactBAATy), subObjBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactBAATy, objExactBTy), subObjBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactBAATy, objExactBBTy), subObjBTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactAATy, objExactBaseTy), subObjBaseTy);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactAATy, objExactTestClassTy), TObj);
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactBAATy, objExactNonUniqueTy), TObj);
  // optional sub obj
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(opt(subObjATy), opt(subObjBTy)), opt(subObjBaseTy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjAATy, opt(subObjABTy)), opt(subObjATy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(opt(subObjATy), subObjBAATy), opt(subObjBaseTy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(opt(subObjBAATy), opt(subObjBTy)), opt(subObjBTy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(opt(subObjBAATy), subObjBBTy), opt(subObjBTy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(opt(subObjAATy), opt(subObjBaseTy)), opt(subObjBaseTy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjAATy, opt(subObjTestClassTy)), opt(TObj));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjBAATy, opt(subObjNonUniqueTy)), opt(TObj));
  // optional sub and exact obj mixed
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(opt(objExactATy), subObjBTy), opt(subObjBaseTy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjAATy, opt(objExactABTy)), opt(subObjATy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(opt(objExactATy), objExactBAATy), opt(subObjBaseTy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjBAATy, opt(objExactBTy)), opt(subObjBTy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(opt(subObjBAATy), objExactBBTy), opt(subObjBTy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(objExactAATy, opt(objExactBaseTy)), opt(subObjBaseTy));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(opt(subObjAATy), objExactTestClassTy), opt(TObj));
  EXPECT_EQ(union_of(subObjBAATy, opt(objExactNonUniqueTy)), opt(TObj));
}